Instantly Placement Tests: How to Automate Deliverability Management for 500+ Mailboxes

Set up automated inbox placement tests in Instantly to monitor deliverability across hundreds of mailboxes, automatically pause failing inboxes, and restore them when healthy.

January 11, 2026 ยท 14 min read

Instantly Deliverability Inbox Placement Automation Email Warmup

Managing deliverability across a handful of mailboxes is straightforward. Managing it across 500 mailboxes is a different problem entirely. The traditional approach of running manual placement tests weekly becomes impossible at scale. By the time you discover a mailbox is hitting spam, it has already wasted hundreds of emails and potentially damaged your domain reputation.

Instantly has introduced automated placement tests that fundamentally change how high-volume senders manage deliverability. Instead of reactive monitoring, teams can now set up fully automated systems that detect deliverability problems, remove failing mailboxes from rotation, and restore them only when healthy.

This guide walks through setting up these automations to create a self-healing email infrastructure that protects your campaigns without constant manual oversight.

Why Automated Placement Testing Matters

The core problem with manual deliverability management is timing. A mailbox can start hitting spam at any moment due to content triggers, reputation shifts, or blacklist additions. If you run placement tests weekly, a problematic mailbox might send 700 emails to spam before you catch the issue.

The math gets worse at scale. With 100 mailboxes, weekly testing means checking 100 accounts manually. Even at 5 minutes per test, that is over 8 hours of work every week just to monitor deliverability. Most teams skip corners, test a subset, or stop testing altogether.

Automated placement tests solve both problems:

  1. Daily detection catches problems within 24 hours instead of 7 days
  2. Zero manual effort after initial setup
  3. Automatic remediation removes bad mailboxes without human intervention
  4. Automatic recovery brings healthy mailboxes back into rotation

According to Validity’s 2025 benchmark data, global inbox placement averaged about 83.5% in 2024. Top-performing programs achieve rates above 95%. The gap between average and excellent deliverability represents real pipeline lost to spam folders.

Understanding Instantly’s Placement Test Feature

Placement tests work by sending your actual campaign content to a network of seed inboxes across major email providers. The system then checks where each email landed: primary inbox, promotions tab, or spam folder.

What the Tests Measure

When you run a placement test in Instantly, you receive:

  • Overall inbox placement percentage across all providers
  • Provider-specific breakdown showing Gmail, Microsoft, and other ESP performance
  • Spam filter analysis identifying content elements triggering filters
  • Blacklist status across major blocklist databases
  • Authentication verification for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC

The key insight is that placement tests use your actual campaign copy. This matters because generic test emails might pass while your specific content triggers spam filters. By testing with real campaign content, you catch issues that only manifest with your actual messaging.

Pricing for Automated Tests

Instantly offers two tiers for placement testing:

  • Growth Inbox Placement ($37.60/month): Unlimited one-time tests, unlimited sending accounts per test
  • Hypergrowth Inbox Placement ($77.60/month): Unlimited automated and recurring tests

The Hypergrowth tier is required for the automation features covered in this guide. At under $100/month for unlimited automated testing across unlimited mailboxes, this represents significant value for teams managing large mailbox pools.

For comparison, running equivalent manual tests through standalone tools like EmailGuard or MailReach at similar scale would cost considerably more and still require manual oversight.

Setting Up Your First Automated Placement Test

Before diving into automation, walk through creating a placement test manually to understand each configuration option.

Step 1: Access Placement Tests

In your Instantly dashboard, navigate to the Placement Tests section. You will see any existing tests along with their recent results.

Step 2: Create a New Test

Click to create a new inbox placement test and configure the basics:

  • Name: Use a descriptive name that identifies the campaign and mailbox group (e.g., “Q1 SaaS Campaign - Primary Domains”)
  • Description: Optional notes about what this test monitors
  • Mode: Select “Automated” for recurring tests

Step 3: Configure Test Timing

For automated tests, set:

  • Days: Which days of the week to run tests (business days recommended)
  • Times: When during those days to execute tests

Running tests during your normal sending hours produces the most accurate results since spam filters may behave differently at different times.

Step 4: Select Geographic Targeting

Choose the regions matching your target audience:

  • North America: United States, Canada
  • Europe: UK, Germany, France, etc.
  • APAC: Australia, Singapore, etc.

Select “Professional” inboxes for B2B campaigns. Consumer-heavy seed lists can distort results since personal Gmail accounts behave differently than Google Workspace.

Step 5: Add Mailboxes to Test

This is where tagging strategy pays off. If your mailboxes are properly tagged in Instantly, you can add entire groups with a single selection. Otherwise, you must add accounts individually.

Tagging recommendation: Before setting up placement tests, ensure all mailboxes are tagged by:

  • Domain group (e.g., “primary-domains”, “secondary-domains”)
  • Campaign type (e.g., “saas-outreach”, “agency-prospecting”)
  • Client (for agencies managing multiple accounts)

Step 6: Select Campaign Content

Choose an existing campaign to use as the test content:

  1. Select the campaign from your active campaigns
  2. Choose which email variant to test (if using A/B testing)
  3. Verify the copy in the preview

Critical: The test sends this exact content. If your campaign copy contains spam triggers, the test will reveal them. This is the intended behavior.

Step 7: Configure Sending Options

  • HTML only: Recommended for most B2B campaigns
  • Timing: Delivery mode (one-by-one recommended)

The Three Essential Automations

Here is where placement tests become transformative. Instantly allows you to trigger actions based on test results. The right combination of automations creates a self-managing system.

Automation 1: Pause on Low Placement

Trigger: If inbox placement goes below 50%

Actions:

  • Pause sending campaigns
  • Wait for 14 days
  • Optionally add a “recovering” tag

This automation removes underperforming mailboxes from your active sending pool. The 50% threshold is aggressive but appropriate. A mailbox placing only half of emails in the inbox is actively harming your campaigns.

Why 14 days? Email reputation requires time to recover. Shorter pauses often result in the mailbox immediately failing again when reactivated. Two weeks of warmup-only activity allows reputation signals to stabilize.

Automation 2: Pause on Blacklist Detection

Trigger: If account or domain is added to any blacklist

Actions:

  • Pause sending campaigns
  • Wait for 14 days
  • Optionally add “blacklisted” tag
  • Optionally send webhook notification

Blacklists are serious reputation signals. Even minor blacklists can cascade into deliverability problems across providers. Immediately removing blacklisted mailboxes from sending prevents further damage.

Note on redundancy: You might wonder if both the placement threshold and blacklist triggers are necessary. In practice, significant blacklist additions cause placement to drop, so the 50% threshold would eventually catch them. However, the blacklist trigger provides faster response for cases where you land on a list but placement has not yet degraded.

Automation 3: Reactivate on Recovery

Trigger: If inbox placement goes above 70%

Actions:

  • Slow ramp sending in campaign
  • Remove “recovering” tag
  • Optionally send webhook notification

This automation completes the self-healing loop. Once a paused mailbox demonstrates healthy placement, it automatically returns to the sending rotation.

Why slow ramp? Jumping immediately back to full sending volume risks re-triggering the original problem. Slow ramping gradually increases daily send limits, similar to the initial warmup process. This protects the recovering mailbox while validating that deliverability remains stable.

Why 70% instead of 50%? The asymmetric thresholds (pause at 50%, resume at 70%) prevent mailboxes from bouncing in and out of rotation. A mailbox hovering around 50% placement would constantly flip between active and paused without the gap.

Advanced Configuration Options

Beyond the core three automations, placement tests support additional triggers and actions for sophisticated workflows.

Additional Triggers

  • Placement goes above X%: Useful for escalating notifications when mailboxes achieve exceptional results
  • Removed from blacklist: Can trigger immediate reactivation rather than waiting for placement recovery
  • Specific provider placement: Trigger based on Gmail-only or Microsoft-only results

Additional Actions

  • Add/remove tags: Enables filtering and reporting on mailbox health
  • Send webhook: Integrates with external systems like Slack, Notion, or custom dashboards
  • Custom wait periods: Adjust pause duration based on severity

Webhook Integration for Team Notifications

For teams that want visibility without checking the Instantly dashboard, webhook notifications provide real-time alerts:

  1. Create a Slack incoming webhook or use a service like Zapier
  2. Add the webhook URL to your automation actions
  3. Configure which events trigger notifications

Recommended notifications:

  • When any mailbox is paused (immediate awareness)
  • When mailboxes recover (confirmation that recovery worked)
  • Weekly summary of mailbox health (ongoing visibility)

Interpreting Placement Test Results

Understanding what the results mean helps you take appropriate action beyond the automated responses.

Reading the Dashboard

Each placement test result shows:

  • Overall placement rate: Your primary health metric
  • Provider breakdown: Where problems are concentrated
  • Trend data: Whether placement is improving or degrading

Provider-Specific Insights

Gmail, Microsoft, and other providers use different filtering algorithms. Common patterns:

Gmail struggles, Microsoft fine: Often indicates content issues. Gmail’s spam filters are more sensitive to certain phrases, formatting, and link patterns.

Microsoft struggles, Gmail fine: May indicate authentication issues or IP reputation problems. Microsoft relies more heavily on sender reputation signals.

Both struggling equally: Usually points to fundamental issues like blacklisting, authentication failures, or severely damaged domain reputation.

When Automated Actions Are Not Enough

The automations handle routine deliverability maintenance. However, some situations require manual investigation:

  • Persistent failures: A mailbox that repeatedly fails and recovers may have underlying issues
  • Domain-wide problems: If all mailboxes on a domain fail simultaneously, the domain itself needs attention
  • Content-triggered spam: If placement drops after launching a new campaign variant, the content needs revision

Best Practices for Placement Test Management

Organize Tests by Domain Group

Rather than one massive test covering all 500 mailboxes, create separate tests for logical groupings:

  • Primary sending domains
  • Secondary/backup domains
  • Client-specific domains (for agencies)
  • Campaign-specific mailbox pools

This organization makes it easier to identify patterns and take targeted action.

Match Test Volume to Sending Capacity

If you operate 500 mailboxes sending 50 emails each daily, that is 25,000 emails. Your placement test infrastructure should validate a representative sample without overwhelming the system.

Coordinate with Warmup

Placement tests and email warmup work together:

  1. New mailboxes warm up for 14+ days before joining active campaigns
  2. Placement tests run on all mailboxes including warming ones
  3. Only mailboxes passing placement thresholds enter the sending rotation
  4. Paused mailboxes continue warmup activity during their recovery period

This creates a quality gate where mailboxes must demonstrate deliverability before receiving campaign traffic.

Regular Review of Automation Thresholds

The 50%/70% thresholds suggested above work for most use cases. However, your specific situation may warrant adjustment:

  • Tighter thresholds (60%/80%): For campaigns where deliverability is critical and you have mailbox capacity to spare
  • Looser thresholds (40%/60%): For high-volume operations where some spam placement is acceptable

Review your actual placement distributions monthly and adjust thresholds based on observed performance.

Comparing Instantly’s Approach to Alternatives

Instantly is not the only platform offering deliverability monitoring. Understanding the alternatives helps evaluate whether this approach fits your stack.

Standalone Placement Testing Tools

Tools like EmailGuard and MailReach provide inbox placement testing as a dedicated service. Their advantages include:

  • Deeper diagnostic detail
  • Platform-agnostic testing
  • Specialized deliverability expertise

However, they lack the automation integration that Instantly provides. You can identify problems but must manually pause and reactivate mailboxes in your sending tool.

Built-in Testing in Other Platforms

Smartlead offers SmartDelivery as an add-on ($49-$599/month) with similar inbox placement testing. The automation capabilities differ, so evaluate based on which platform you use for sending.

Hybrid Approaches

Some teams use Instantly for sending with external tools for monitoring:

  1. Run placement tests through MailReach or EmailGuard
  2. Use their results to inform manual mailbox management in Instantly
  3. Accept the manual overhead in exchange for deeper diagnostic data

This approach makes sense when you need specialized deliverability consulting or more detailed forensic analysis than Instantly provides.

Implementation Checklist

Before launching automated placement tests, verify these elements are configured:

Mailbox Organization

  • All mailboxes tagged by domain group
  • Tags reflect logical testing groups
  • Warmup enabled on all mailboxes

Test Configuration

  • Tests created for each mailbox group
  • Automated mode enabled
  • Daily schedule configured for business hours
  • Geographic targeting matches your audience
  • Campaign content selected for each test

Automation Rules

  • Pause trigger at 50% placement or lower
  • Blacklist detection trigger enabled
  • Reactivation trigger at 70% placement or higher
  • Slow ramp configured for reactivation
  • Appropriate wait periods set (14 days recommended)

Notifications

  • Webhook configured for pause events
  • Team notification channel established
  • Escalation process defined for persistent failures

Monitoring Plan

  • Weekly review of overall mailbox health
  • Monthly threshold evaluation
  • Quarterly cleanup of chronically failing mailboxes

What This Changes for Your Operations

With automated placement tests running, your deliverability management shifts from reactive to proactive:

Before: Discover deliverability problems when reply rates drop. Investigate manually. Identify which mailboxes are hitting spam. Pause them. Monitor recovery. Manually reactivate.

After: System automatically identifies problems, removes bad mailboxes, allows recovery time, and restores healthy mailboxes. You receive notifications and review weekly summaries.

The time savings scale with mailbox count. At 50 mailboxes, manual management is tedious but feasible. At 500 mailboxes, automation is the only practical approach.

More importantly, automated management improves outcomes. Faster detection means fewer wasted emails. Consistent recovery periods mean more durable fixes. Slow ramp reactivation means fewer repeated failures.

For teams serious about cold email at scale, automated placement testing is no longer optional. It is the infrastructure layer that makes high-volume sending sustainable.

Have a Guide to Share?

If you've built a workflow worth documenting, we'd love to feature it.

Submit a Guide